Posts categorized "Charleston Fire"

July 11, 2009

Mayor Joe Riley Clarifies Remarks Concerning Former Chief Rusty Thomas

Charleston Mayor Joe Riley didn't apologize for supporting former fire chief Rusty Thomas. Instead he took the approach many expected and "clarified" his remarks.

Riley said he wanted to clarify remarks made at a city council meeting wherein he states some Charleston firefighters believe he said Thomas made the right leadership decisions. Actually Riley's spokeswoman clarified the remarks because Riley, in a legal move, said he couldn't remember what the comments were.

While the Charleston Fire Department is moving forward the accountability for the fire is just getting started. It's thought Riley, and others, will have to clarify further remarks. While uninformed people thought the issues surrounding the fire were over the fact is the issues are now starting.

June 26, 2009

Smoke Reading Seminar in Charleston

The Charleston Fire Department will host a two day seminar on Reading Smoke and The Firefighters Interior List on June 29 or 30, 2009. The seminar will be held at the College of Charleston Simmons Center for the Fine Arts.

This is an excellent opportunity for firefighters to learn the essentials of reading smoke and to discuss the importance of understanding the interior environment of a fire.

Registration is $25 per person. Email your name, department, phone number and which day you plan to attend to BrownDE@ci.charleston.sc.us

The seminar will be conducted by Retired Chief William Godfrey.

June 21, 2009

Smoke Reading Seminar In Charleston June 29, 30

Ukfire

The Charleston Fire Department will host a two day seminar on Reading Smoke and The Firefighters Interior List on June 29 or 30, 2009. The seminar will be held at the College of Charleston Simmons Center for the Fine Arts.

This is an excellent opportunity for firefighters to learn the essentials of reading smoke and to discuss the importance of understanding the interior environment of a fire.

Registration is $25 per person. Email your name, department, phone number and which day you plan to attend to BrownDE@ci.charleston.sc.us

The seminar will be conducted by Retired Chief William Godfrey.

June 20, 2009

Charleston Fire Department Featuring Seminar

The Charleston Fire Department will host a two day seminar on Reading Smoke and The Firefighters Interior List on June 29 or 30, 2009. The seminar will be held at the College of Charleston Simmons Center for the Fine Arts.

This is an excellent opportunity for firefighters to learn the essentials of reading smoke and to discuss the importance of understanding the interior environment of a fire.

Registration is $25 per person. Email your name, department, phone number and which day you plan to attend to BrownDE@ci.charleston.sc.us

The seminar will be conducted by Retired Chief William Godfrey.

June 18, 2009

Attend Seminar On Smoke Reading in Charleston

The Charleston Fire Department will host a two day seminar on Reading Smoke and The Firefighters Interior List on June 29 or 30, 2009. The seminar will be held at the College of Charleston Simmons Center for the Fine Arts.

This is an excellent opportunity for firefighters to learn the essentials of reading smoke and to discuss the importance of understanding the interior environment of a fire.

Registration is $25 per person. Email your name, department, phone number and which day you plan to attend to BrownDE@ci.charleston.sc.us

The seminar will be conducted by Retired Chief William Godfrey.

Charleston Should Absorb Ineffective St. Andrews Fire Department

The Charleston Fire Department is more capable of serving the citizens of West Ashley than if they continue to share duties with the St. Andrews Fire Department. At best it is an exercise in poor governing while at worst it is dangerous.

St. Andrews is unable to provide the effective services citizens need. From staffing issues at St. Andrews that Charleston got hammered on to ineffective leadership the wise choice for all citizens is to either annex into the city or have the city take over all services.

One of the issues is wasted tax payer dollars. A Quint was purchased last year and now runs as an engine only. The extra money spent on the aerial ladder was a waste of taxpayer dollars. In an economy such as this one no money can be wasted on trucks that aren't utilized to their full capacity.

Over the past year stations have been run by people who aren't ranked high enough to act company officer. Instead back up drivers have been placed into service as acting officers. They have little to no training as officers and in light of the Sofa Super Store fire one cannot imagine any department acting in such a reckless manner.

Charleston was criticized for their approach to fighting fire yet no one has inquired as to why St. Andrews functions as a barely literate department. From the perspective of calls run they respond to less than one thousand from four stations. This is less than many volunteer departments in the state.

We implore Mayor Joe Riley and members of City Council to absorb the St. Andrews Fire Department into the city. It would benefit all residents as well as firefighters.

Clearly the Charleston Fire Department is more than capable of providing the level of service needed for the citizens of West Ashley.

June 17, 2009

Observations On The Second Anniversary Of the Sofa Super Store

June 18, 2007 transformed the lives of many people in the Charleston area. In the course of an afternoon and evening life went from the joys of a summer June day to the horror of lost friends and colleagues. For this author that day changed the fire service forever.

All who wear, or who have worn, the badge of a Charleston firefighter understand the philosophy of pre-2007. You pulled up, went in and fought fire no matter how hot, how tough, or how dangerous the situation. It was part of being a firefighter in an old port city known for independence of thought and sense of history.

Having had the honor of wearing a uniform in Charleston it was never lost on me that the people who were worth something would always be beside you inside, no matter what. It was an attitude that prevaled for over a century.

Time, in its own peculiar way, straightens out those situations. Charleston was walking the razors edge with no room to spare. A slight slip would mean tragedy. Instead of a slip a major fall, a cascading series of events materialized that led to the deaths of nine brave souls.

It's clear now that tradition wasn't at fault. Tradition is keeping alive the best of what works and discarding the rest as a useless by product of days long past. It wasn't tradition or the culture of extinguishment that killed nine brothers. It was a failure of leadership and command, bundled together, throwing out hints of impending doom and then striking with vengeance.

For the life of me I can't forget the image of Billy Hutchinson smiling or Earl Drayton smirking. Mike Benke, sitting at the table in engine 3, waiting for our engineer to show up to relieve him. Louis Mulkey I still see on his first day, inside the dayroom/kitchen of engine 2, introducing himself. These are the men I knew better so it is only natural I remember them clearly.

We remember people by the effect they have on us. Each of the fallen impacted someones life, brought joy, gave life to a civilian who was bound for death. They were firefighters, each of them, ready to answer a call to service. They responded, one final time, to a building housing nothing of importance save one human life.

They went inside to put out a fire. In some other time, in some other way, I see them walking out, grimy faces, smiling, looking to take a breather from hard work. Patting each other on the back, making jokes and thinking only that they had just knocked down another fire. That's how I see them in my minds eye, forever as they appeared prior to entering that  building, never aging, always living.

All of the families deserved more years with them. They sacrificed their loved ones not because they wanted to but because their loved ones served in a profession of sacrifice. I think of them and my heart weeps for their pain, suffering and moments lost. What gives me hope is an eternal reunion of some kind where they see those nine men who died as brothers, alive again, smiling, full of life.

Where does Charleston stand now? There are issues still unresolved that will play out in the courts. The fire department is moving forward though, step by step, never far removed from the night of June 18, 2007. A new chief, new deputy chief of operations and firefighters are standing guard over Charleston as these words are written. Each of them is prepared to go in harms way ever mindful of the costs.

Despite personality disagreements there is no one in Charleston who wants to see failure. From this author's perspective it is my sincere hope all members advance the department to where it should be, to have the leadership it never had despite having firefighters who would breach the wall of hell to get the job done. From the chief to the deputies, the assistant chiefs to the battalions, the Captains to the firefighters I wish nothing but the very best.

One day maybe we will all be rejoined in some place where youth, vitality and a common brotherhood link us all. Each of us, a proud bearer of the Charleston patch, washed in blood but raised again by men and women of iron.

Charleston Fire Department Hosts Seminar On Reading Smoke

The Charleston Fire Department will host a two day seminar on Reading Smoke and The Firefighters Interior List on June 29 or 30, 2009. The seminar will be held at the College of Charleston Simmons Center for the Fine Arts.

This is an excellent opportunity for firefighters to learn the essentials of reading smoke and to discuss the importance of understanding the interior environment of a fire.

Registration is $25 per person. Email your name, department, phone number and which day you plan to attend to BrownDE@ci.charleston.sc.us

The seminar will be conducted by Retired Chief William Godfrey.

June 09, 2009

Charleston Prepares For Anniversary of Sofa Super Store Fire

Firefighters in Charleston are preparing for a very emotional remembrance of the nine men who lost their lives on June 18, 2007 at the Sofa Super Store. From trying to block it out to planning trips to the site different firefighters deal with it in different ways.

The one constant is the 9. Firefighters think about their lost brothers as they go about changing a department that was found to be decades behind the rest of the country. In some areas that is no longer true and this anniversary will show Charleston firefighters are ahead of many other departments.

Some on the department weren't there two years ago when the fire happened. Turn over has been high with people leaving or going out on disability. The new employees will learn to observe the 18th in the spirit of change.

Some issues remain unresolved. The legal fights, current and future, remain ever present. Firefighters, however, continue to answer calls.

Nearby the St. Andrews Fire Department is also remembering the Charleston 9. St. Andrews was there early on and worked the Charley side of the building and made the lone rescue of the night. They too are remembering the long night of June 18, 2007.

June 08, 2009

Gas Leak Forces Evacuation At Bishop England High School

Charleston firefighters are working a gas leak on Daniel Island at the private high school, Bishop England, as gas crews work to contain the leak. The school was in summer session when firefighters received the call.

Bishop England and Daniel Island are isolated from the rest of the city. Nearby North Charleston and Mount Pleasant are closer than other Charleston City units.  Anything above a reduced first alarm requires units to travel a great distance unless the previously mentioned departments send in units.

June 05, 2009

Run For The 9

The Run for the Charleston 9 is fast approaching. It will take place on June 14, 2009. Here are some deatils:

The run will take place in beautiful Palmetto Islands County Park in Mt. Pleasant, SC. The track will cover tarmac, trails and boardwalks taking you through scenic marshes and spectacular natural corridores. Once inside the park, you will be directed to Big Oak Shelter where check in will be held and the band "Not So Serious" will be playing.

Please plan to check in before 8:45am, as the race will start at 9am. Walkers are welcome. The starting line will be in a large green meadow where you will also find sponsor booths, and a fire truck. This is a family event where kids are welcome and children under 12 are free. For an additional fee there is also a Splash Island Water Park for the family to enjoy. Come out and support your local firefighters, and we hope to see you at the starting line!

You can register online at www.local61.com and clicking on the red "LINKS" button on the left of the page, or www.active.com and typing "run for the 9" into the event search bar to the right of the page.

May 27, 2009

Charleston 9 Memorial Site Would Move Headquarters In Charleston

An ambitious plan to honor the Charleston 9 would include a memorial garden and a new headquarters facility for the Charleston Fire Department. The plan was released as the second anniversary of the Sofa Super Store looms.

The project would provide a place for people to come and remember the nine fallen heroes. It would also serve to move the fire chief from the antiquated Central Station to a more professional setting West of the Ashley. It would also serve to remind the current and future chiefs of department of the consequences of failing their employees.

May 17, 2009

Charleston Again Faces Public Scrutiny On Fire Issues

The Public Safety Committee is a waste of time and one former chairman say's had the group met more often maybe they could have prevented the Sofa Super Store Tragedy. Glenn Smith of the Post & Courier has an excellent article in today's paper discussing these issues and more.

At the heart of it all is Mayor Joe Riley. We will begin to discuss why the department can't change because politics prevents any real progress. If the department makes a quantum leap it is an admission of failure on the part of the city for past actions and in-actions.

May 13, 2009

Charleston Fire Department Command Staff In Need Of Overhaul

A little more than a month from now the second anniversary of the Sofa Super Store Fire will be observed. Since the fateful day in June of 2007 a new President has been elected changing the way American's look at leadership. In Charleston, however, the change is hardly felt.

Though firefighters began to change the way the department ran there have been clear indications Charleston's leadership issues still exist. From questionable promotions to actions on the fireground that reveal a command level ignorance the change at the top is measured in millimeters.

It's not just poor decision making in uniform but some of the same actions existing prior to June 18, 2007 that are once again the norm rather than the exception. Questionable decisions by Tom Carr's command staff have eroded firefighters faith in his ability to actually run the department any differently than his predecessor.

We will discuss this further in today's podcast.

May 07, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Association Offers Than You's, Reminder

Charleston Firefighters Association, Local 61 of the IAFF, wants to thank all who participated in the funeral for John Antley of the Naval Weapons Station Fire Department. Antley lost his battle with cancer.

President Bill Haigler of local 61 wants to thank the counselors from the peer support group, local firefighters, honor guard teams from the Charleston Fire Department, North Charleston Fire Department, Mount Pleasant Fire Department and the Army National Guard. He also extends a warm than you to Sheriff Al Cannon for providing escort services.

In addition he wants to remind firefighters that Clinton Jones, recently profiled in the media, will make an appearance in city council chambers on May 12. Clint is fighting for insurance and has met stiff opposition from the city. Clint is out on disability as a result of the events of June 18, 2007.

Firefighter Sacrifice Means Little To Charleston

The City of Charleston has had almost two years to take care of current, disabled and retired firefighters but some question the decency of the city as it relates to the fire department. Not only have firefighters been ignored but common questions normally just a phone call away are left unanswered.

The only success story in Charleston in the care of firefighters is the firefighter support team. Literally saving lives the team has built a sterling reputation. The same cannot be said for city offices.

We will discuss this in-depth in today's podcast.

Charleston Firefighters Can't Depend On City

It's bad enough when active firefighters can't get the City of Charleston to listen to their concerns but now add yet another group fed up with the way Charleston does business. Retired members of the department aren't happy with the way the city responds to their questions about health care.

It's not just the below average health care coverage. Instead it is the way the city treats retired and disabled firefighters like Clint Jones, who gave an interview to WCBD detailing his concerns. It doesn't stop there though.

Current firefighters complain the new chief doesn't listen anymore than human resources. Further, some add, the people he has chosen to fill critical roles don't listen on issues of safety and operations. One firefighters stated one of the highest ranking chief officers admitted to forgetting about 2 in and 2 out.

Add operational issues to low morale and mix it with disabled firefighters not getting responses on questions and you are right back to pre-June 18th conditions.

May 04, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Question Past History Of Command Staff

Charleston firefighters wonder how several personnel were promoted to higher ranking positions considering the promoted people were involved in several training videos that made news during the post June 18 tragedy in Charleston.

Having command staff members who have embarrassed the department in critical roles continues to plague the department. One firefighter spoke about the loss of respect for Fire Chief Tom Carr since he approved the promotions.

Some wonder if the calls to promote several people were made from city hall and whether there may be a political, or some other, connection. However, Chief Carr maintains the most qualified people were promoted which is precisely what the former chief used to say.

May 03, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Speak Out to Post & Courier

In an exclusive, Glenn Smith of the Post & Courier interviewed Charleston firefighters who feel as though recent promotions, and tactics, are still being done the same old way. Tom Carr, the current fire chief, said the department was moving forward. According to the article others beg to differ.

"I understand his plate is full and overwhelming, but at the same time, they are gambling with our lives with incompetents running the scenes," said one firefighter, who requested anonymity. "Who is on the end of the nozzle? Not Carr. It's us."

I encourage everyone to read the article by the Post & Courier. It shows both sides but it highlights what FirefighterHourly.com has been told over the last month. The promotions are seriously deficient and tactics have stayed the same.

One note about having fire chiefs from other departments sit in on the promotion of the departments Assistant Chiefs - one of the departments helping out is led by a Carr protege. This is hardly "fair" nor is it wise.

Now that firefighters have spoken to the mainstream media we will begin to discuss the issues in-depth in Charleston. The promotions are especially interesting considering how closely involved a few of the new chiefs were in practices that could have resulted in severe issues for the city had someone pushed it. Are these the new leaders the public wants?

Read the entire article from the Post & Courier here.

May 01, 2009

Run For The Charleston 9 Scheduled

A run in memory of the Charleston 9 will take place on June 14, 2009 at:

Palmetto Islands County Park
444 Needlerush Parkway

Loated in Mount Pleasant the park features activities for children as well as adults. More information can be found here.

April 26, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Battle High Rise Fire

A fire at Joseph Floyd Manor, located at King and Mt. Pleasant Street, sent residents scurrying into the streets as firefighters took to the stairs to extinguish a blaze. Smoke was thick on the 12th floor as firefighters assisted residents down into the fresh air outside.

The equivalent of two alarms was on scene around 1700 last night. The Joseph Floyd Manor houses residents, many of whom are elderly.

April 24, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Critical Of Department

Charleston firefighters who fully supported Tom Carr are now coming forward saying the chief is almost non-existent, has catered to the old boy network and is presiding over a department with crippled leadership.

Recent moves to elevate people into positions of authority with little to no training combined with Carr embracing the remaining old school command officers has alienated firefighters and other command staff.

Determined not to let the department continue to slide firefighters are talking to FirefighterHourly.com as well as traditional media. They say the proof is in the records of those who have been promoted, those who lack even the most basic firefighting certifications from the state, and the "morale problems people" who have been appointed to Assistant Chief positions.

Training is reportedly stifled and firefighters who were once talking glowingly of the training division now say training is cut off due to some of the old guard being promoted. In short, the department is barely staying above water.


April 18, 2009

John Tippett Excellent Candidate For Charleston Fire Department

Despite a massive failure in process make no mistake that the man chosen to lead the operations division in the Charleston Fire department is a good choice.  Educated, involved and experienced he will bring these attributes to a department long devoid of the above.

His presence will elevate Charleston to a new level and given timehe will alter the way Charleston does business. In  fact Charleston not only hired their new operations chief but also the next Fire Chief.  There's little doubt Tippett will ascend to that position when Carr retires.

April 17, 2009

Charleston Hires New Fire Operations Chief

A man who once worked for new Charleston Fire Chief Tom Carr is now the new Deputy Chief of Operations in Charleston. Appointed through a non-competitive process, John Tippett will take over as the deputy for operations.

The move isn't surprising except that it fails to offer a wide range of candidates, including minority candidates, the opportunity to compete for the job. This is similar to how previous appointments were made by the former administration. While many of us were sold on the possibility of a wide range of candidates competing for the job it's apparent the move is status quo, still, in Charleston.

As one command staff member stated "This is nothing new. It's what we are used to."

Chief Tippett is an excellent choice but the perception is the goold old boy process really never left Charleston.

March 16, 2009

Firefighters May Stage Own "No Confidence" Vote

Lowcountry firefighters are discussing delivering a no confidence vote in the fire chief and two assistant chiefs. The possible move is due to recent promotions and the feeling no one is listening to firefighter concerns. It also marks a break from the local because said members are upset at the lack of response to promotions.

More information as it becomes available.

March 11, 2009

Mulkey's Donate RIT Bags To Charleston Fire Department

The parents of Louis Mulkey, killed on June 18 in the Sofa Super Store Fire, donated money for two RIT bags to be placed on apparatus, most of which still do not have them.

The Mulkey's appeared with Local 61 President Bill Haigler and the Charleston Chief.

The donation presentation comes just a day after an email went out with a controversial promotion. It's not uncommon for bad news to be released under the light of good news and this is what some firefighters believe happened.

The Sofa Super Store fire led to scathing reports about the department resulting in the departure of the fire chief.

Louis Mulkey was a beloved firefighter and coach at Summerville High School.

March 10, 2009

O'Donald, Lloyd and Suggs Promoted To Assistant Chief

Chief Tom Carr of the Charleston Fire Department has promoted Robert O'Donald, Spence Suggs and Raymond Lloyd to the positions of Assistant Chief. The email Carr sent out said the three competed in a one day assessment involving officers from tow in state and one out of state department(s).

The moves will be controversial for many firefighters because it is basically the same line up one would have expected to see if the previous chief remained in control with the exception of Suggs,who is respected.

The bottom line is the chief has the authority to choose who he has around him. Whether through an assessment or picking based on hair color it's his command staff. If it works out well he will receive kudos. If it doesn't, if the same issues crop up, Chief Carr will face a very upset body of firefighters.

We wish the best to the Charleston firefighters. They alone understand the department. They will be the ones who reap the benefits or who pay the price for the decisions. However, the decision was Tom Carr's. Firefighters understand that as well.

Charleston Firefighters To Sell Barbecue To Raise Money For Cancer Victim

Charleston's bravest protect the citizens of Charleston daily and now they need help raising money for a family member of one of their own. Battalion Chief John Poston is a longtime member of the department. His daughter has melanoma and after undergoing surgery we need to raise money to help the family out.

The Charleston Firefighters Association (Local 61) will be selling barbecue at station 13 on Folly Road March 14, 2009. Please plan to stop by and contribute as well as take part in the barbecue. Local departments will also be sending fire apparatus over to station 13 as a show of support.

March 08, 2009

Will There Be Accountability In Charleston Over Death Of Nine Firefighters

The issue of accountability is ever present in discussions about the Sofa Super Store fire on June 18, 2007. The vast majority of discussions indicate people want to see someone held accountable for the deaths of nine Charleston firefighters.

There are a few who oppose the idea for several reasons:

  1. Hasn't there been enough?
  2. The officers in charge have to live with failure.

  3. People are greedy.

Some contend enough has happened, therefore the accountability phase is over. Others state those in charge have to carry their failure with them for the rest of their lives. One believes the accountability is basically about greed rather than any sort of justice.

Number one is ridiculous because "too much attention" has never passed for justice.

Number three is also ridiculous because it is a broad statement.

Number two is the chief reason given for leaving everything alone. However, this approach is only justice if the persons involved believe an error was committed. Even the Mayor of Charleston has given comments leading people to believe the department was well led the night of June 18.

If the Mayor feels the department was well led how do those who were responsible for the day to day operations of the department feel? The Routley Report was a condemnation of leadership, planning, training, and operations. In short, almost every aspect of the department was found wanting.

The NIOSH report was extraordinary in scope. It too revealed a host of issues, many being corrected or already corrected. This report was reviewed by Vincent Dunn, Alan Brunacini and John Salka.

So where does accountability begin and end?

Do we want to live in a society where those who are given the responsibility of protecting life are merely allowed to retire or move on, or in several cases, thrive under new leadership?

Or, should we say enough is enough and move on?


March 04, 2009

Dr. Harry Carter Calls Out Charleston Mayor Joe Riley

One of the most respected names in the fire service has once again called out Mayor Joe Riley for comments the mayor made defending the way the Charleston Fire Department responded to the Sofa Super Store.

Dr. Carter stated in his Firehouse.com column:

Let me suggest that this new honor be called the "Dumb-Ass of the Day (Week, Month, Year, Decade, Century, Eon) Award". To be considered for this auspicious award, one need only say, or do something which is either supremely stupid, or audaciously outrageous. Given the number of e-mails which I receive each week from around the world, I would suspect that competition for this honor will be stiff indeed.

I offer Mayor Joe Riley of Charleston, as the most clueless politician on the face of the globe, this week.

As my evidence of his actions which merit the award of this new honor, I offer the following comment from the ABC television affiliate's Charleston News 4 website. Mrs. Dorothy Hutchinson, who lost her son Billy in the sofa store fire back in 2007 stood up at the Charleston City Council meeting and demanded that someone be held accountable for the death of her son and the other eight fire personnel.

In her address to the meeting she made the following statement: "Mayor Riley, these nine men gave 132 years of their life to the fire department so I'm asking you again, as a mother and a co-worker of these nine men, that there be (someone) held accountable for these deaths." Not an unreasonable request in my book.

In reply to Mrs. Hutchinson's call for accountability, Mayor Riley made the following brilliant comment: "Brave people lost their lives serving the citizens of our city and seeking to put out a fire beyond anyone's expectations. They were well led and everybody did the best they could."

What planet has this man descended from? How in the world can he make such a comment in light of the reports issued by both NIOSH and the Routley Committee? Is this man illiterate or merely ignorant? If there was one message which came through loudly and clearly from both of these reports, the fire department, as it existed in Charleston in 2007, was an abomination on the face of God's Green Earth!

This commentary is being met with great delight from all corners of the fire service, especially among those who realize the City of Charleston Fire Department was grossly unprepared to meet any of the challenges it faced on June 18, 2007.

Despite our pledge to stay out of the accountability phase so many people have written in about letting the former command staff just walk away we are committed to reporting what firefighters say.

Charleston firefighters we spoke to say the Mayor is hopelessly lost and that his comments, while not denounced by the local, are upsetting to the rank and file.  Several firefighters say they plan on asking that the mayor formally apologize to the families for his remarks or resign.

March 02, 2009

Charleston NIOSH Report Was Reviewed By Fire Service Professionals

The NIOSH report released on the Sofa Super Store fire wasn't just a report released by a federal agency or people who are part of the "safety police", as some allege. A number of the most respected names in the fire service provided expert technical review of the document, providing expertise born on the fireground in cities like New york and Phoenix.

Deputy Chief Vince Dunn, FDNY (Retired), Chief Alan Brunacini, Phoenix Fire Department (Retired), and Battalion Chief John Salka, FDNY provided technical reviews of the report on what has become one of the worst managed disasters in recent fire service memory. In addition Gordon Routley, Kevin Roche, Ken Farmer, and Nelson Bryner also reviewed the report.

We will have more in the podcast.

February 27, 2009

Charleston Modifies Collection Policy For Firefighters

A meeting produced modified collecting directives for Charleston firefighters. Instead of focusing on solely on safety the department will allow members to step off curbs when traffic is not moving. This is an improvement from previous years but still exposes firefighters to vehicles.

Originally the department banned the collections on the street but a meeting yesterday morning changed some peoples minds. Thus, the new directive was issued by Deputy Chief Frank Finley.

Several firefighters expressed frustration with the modification. Both insisted the department made the right decision to move collections off the street. Now, they say, the message sent indicates to them a weakness of will power. This author disagrees but understands how mixed signals can indicate weakness.

Charleston will raise money via different methods. A hockey game with the FDNY is one such way and staff are working on other methods.

February 26, 2009

Charleston Firefighters Won't Collect In Streets

Charleston firefighters will no longer stand in traffic to collect for charity. The move is designed to prevent injuries or worse and also to alleviate driver concerns, over the years, of firefighters standing in the middle of traffic.

Firefighters speaking to FirefighterHourly.com applaud the move.

Cfdp

February 25, 2009

Charleston Mayor Joe Riley Fails To Understand Sofa Super Store Fire

Many people were caught off guard by Mayor Riley's comments to the local media following a city council meeting. Having been assured the city learned from the tragedy of June 18, 2007, this author and others are stunned to hear what the mayor said last night. The last three hours have been spent on the phone with firefighters, politicians and family. All are caught off guard.

In what can only be described as a rejection of what experts have stated to him at both the local and federal level, Charleston Mayor Joe Riley stated the department was "well led" during the Sofa Super Store Fire.

Speaking to WCIV Channel 4, Mayor Riley stated:

“Brave people lost their lives serving the citizens of our city and seeking to put out a fire beyond anyone’s expectations. They were well led and everybody did the best they could,” said Mayor Riley.

While the Mayor has a right to his personal opinion he speaks for the city. If the city feels as though the department was well led during the previous chiefs tenure, how will they be able to adequately judge future developments in departments citywide?

Everyone didn't do the best they could because leaders violated most of the sound firefighting procedures known to be in existence. The Routley Report, paid for by the Charleston taxpayer and the NIOSH report, confirm the inadequacy of the previous command staff.

It would be wise for the Mayor of Charleston to explain the context within which he made the above statement. No one questions the bravery of the fallen nine but to state in the same paragraph they were well led is a mockery of what most feel was a serious process over the last 20 months.

While there are still legal processes to go through in civil court the Mayor owes it to all involved to clarify his position. Failure to do so will hurt what credibility the city has built up with the hiring of Chief Tom Carr and the implementation of new procedures.

In short, unless the Mayor revises his statement to confirm he agrees with the report he commissioned there will be little any chief can do to restore confidence to the department.

February 24, 2009

New Deputy Chief To Blaze Trail In Charleston

Frank Finley is walking down a path he will create.  As the first Deputy Chief of Administration, Finley is now part of the senior staff of the Charleston Fire Department. He will oversee areas long ignored in the department.

The position was reccomended by the Routley Panel after the Sofa Super Store Fire phase I report was released. Chief Tom Carr has chosen Finley to set the standard for all subsequent Deputy Chiefs.

A Deputy Chief of Operations will be sought sometime in May. The position will be open to applicants nationwide.

February 23, 2009

Frank Finley Named Admin Deputy Chief In Charleston Fire Department

One of two deputy chief positions has been filled by Chief Thomas Carr as he named Battalion Chief Frank Finley Deputy Chief of Administration. Finley has spent his entire career in the Charleston Fire Department.

He served as a Captain in both Engine 7 and 8 as well as his time as a battalion chief. He also served as the deputy chief under the interim chief.

The position of Deputy Chief of Operations will be filled later this year. This next appointment will be critical.

February 18, 2009

Participation By Command Staff Member From Charleston Stirs Department, Others

The apparent inclusion of a member of the command staff in a conference has stirred firefighters and family to voice their opinions both to FirefighterHourly.com,other websites and traditional media.

The command staff member in question was a vocal proponent of the previous chief and apparently spoke in front of firefighters on numerous occasions detailing complaints about the city hired Routley Panel. The panel, along with NIOSH, showed the previous adminsitration of the fire department was well below standard.

Yet, states one firefighter, this command staff member will make a trip to speak to other firefighters out of state about the night of June 18th. This despite the command staff members apparent assertion little went wrong. The firefighter, along with what he states are a growing number of firefighters, will make their voices heard to the city and residents.

The fire department stated he wasn't representing the department but firefighters and family don't buy it. They question the timing, the expertise of the command officer and also wonder aloud if his trip is to do a bit of revisionist history telling.

One politician spoke of his concern over this being possible. He wondered why the new chief would allow this type of public embarassment to take place. 

More later today.

February 16, 2009

Harry Carter On The Charleston NIOSH Report

Harry Carter is often called the conscience of the fire service. Devoted to firefighter well being the retired Newark, New Jersey battalion chief has written several articles on the Sofa Super Store Fire and Charleston in particular.

His latest commentary is perhaps his most direct to date. You can read it here on Firehouse.com

Here are a few quotes from the article.

(NIOSH) reviewed departmental polices, procedures, and operations. At the end of the day they found that a whole host of things were either done incorrectly, ignored, or not done to any acceptable extent.

It should be prominently noted that the NIOSH investigation indicated that departmental training, "...at the time of the incident did not meet NFPA 1001, Standard for Firefighter Professional Qualifications" (NIOSH, 2009, p. 7). How in the world can you hold yourself up to the public as a real fire department in the absence of real, standards-based training?

I find it hard to believe that a major metropolitan department, such as Charleston, did not have written operational guidelines. That is unconscionable. My little, old Adelphia Fire Company in New Jersey, has had a set of written operational guidelines for nearly 20 years.

At the end of the day I have but a single comment to make. This is a tragedy which did not have to occur. However, thanks to a city fire department leadership team steeped in the long-gone traditions of some far-ago time these nine individuals were sacrificed upon the altar of organizational ignorance.

February 12, 2009

Sofa Super Store NIOSH Report States Message Clearly

A command failure prior to and during the Sofa Super Store led to the deaths of nine men on June 18, 2007. NIOSH released their long awaited report and though it contained a bit of information not discussed elsewhere the report basically agrees with the Routley report.

Systemic failure within Charleston's command staff  prior to June 18, 2007 set up the department for failure. There is little hope one could argue they knew nothing about water supply, communications, attack lines, mutual aid or any of the issues brought up in the report. A probationary firefighter will know some of the issues. Were modern practices simply ignored?

Clearly the command staff failed to act, ignoring modern tactics, equipment, and practices readily available in several issues of a trade magazine. This wasn't a bad fire. This was a wholesale failure leading to the deaths of Charleston firefighters. The question becomes one of negligence.

That will be decided by peers.

NIOSH Report On Nine Charleston Firefighters Causes Grief To Emerge

The NIOSH report release will cause emotions among firefighters and civilians. The details of the Sofa Super Store fire have already been released in the Routley Report but the NIOSH release brings the subject to the forefront once again.

June 18, 2007 changed many lives, almost too many to contemplate. The post fire period was very difficult for all involved but especially for the families. The Charleston Firefighter Support Team along with firefighters from around the nation worked to help all Charleston firefighters. Sadly, firefighters from neighboring St. Andrews, who also felt the loss, did not receive Critical Incident Debriefing.

The former chief was forced out and an interim chief stepped in until Thomas Carr was appointed to bring the department into the 21st century. There has been significant change and much for Charleston firefighters to be proud of during the last months.

What remains are the memories of nine men lost in a tragic blaze. We should and must honor them through training and dedication to sound principles, rejecting ignorance and embracing learning.

The Charleston 9

Captain William "Billy" Hutchinson

Captain Mike Benke

Captain Louis Mulkey

Engineer Brad Baity

Firefighter Earl Drayton

Firefighter Melvin Champaign

Firefighter Brandon Thompson

Firefighter Mark Kelsey

Firefighter Michael French

9brothers 

"Today we may say aloud before an awe-struck world, 'We are still masters of our fate. We still are captain of our souls.'"

WS Churchill

NIOSH Report Press Release From City of Charleston

The City of Charleston Fire Department received a copy of the final NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health) report related to the death of nine firefighters at the Sofa Super Store fire on June 18, 2007 today.  In accordance with the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, the NIOSH Fire Fighter Fatality Investigation and Prevention Program (FFFIPP) routinely conducts investigations of firefighter line-of-duty deaths to formulate recommendations for the purpose of preventing future deaths and injuries.   The program does not seek to place fault or blame on fire departments or individual firefighters, but to learn from these tragic events and prevent future related incidents.  Chief Thomas Carr will discuss the report and address the media today

February 12, 2009 at 2:00pm at the Charleston Fire Department Headquarters 46.5 Wentworth Street Charleston, SC 29401. 

NIOSH Report On Charleston 9 Released

The NIOSH report on the deaths of nine Charleston firefighters is now released. We will cover it in depth in two special podcasts. Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

February 05, 2009

According to Paper Charleston Fire Department Training Has Been Cut

Charleston firefighters told FirefighterHourly.com a few weeks ago the training budget had been cut. We inquired and found out the department would bring in speakers to help offset the cost of travel for firefighters to attend training sessions. Therefore it was concluded the cuts were on paper rather than anything of substance.

This morning in the Post & Courier reporter Ron Menchaca discussed the grant Charleston received for staffing and at the end dropped in this paragraph:

Carr said he didn't get everything he requested in his first budget as the city's fire chief. But given the state of the economy, he said he can live with cuts in training and travel.

This hasn't been received very well this morning. Email came pouring in denouncing the move. In fact the first email came from a media member. Firefighters then began to write in with a couple very angry. It's understandable given the importance placed on training in the wake of the arrival of the new chief. While the comment seems dire perhaps the cuts in training are on paper.

Firefighters will be treated to nationally recognized speakers to help offset travel expenses. The training division is still teaching firefighters and a recruit class will soon makes its way into the front doors of the Charleston Fire Department to begin their training.

Still it won't be enough to convince the majority that the city threw away training at a critical time. We will attempt to get answers today.

Grant For Charleston Fire Department Required Shrewd Thinking

Some departments received grants similar to Charleston but were unable to use them because the city/county side of the money hadn't been allocated. Chief Tom Carr in Charleston along with city staff went on the assumption they would receive the grant and planned accordingly.

Now Charleston will welcome 20 + firefighters to the floor this year in addition to any previous positions allocated. This is a sharp departure from much of the nation. Layoffs are occurring along with dangerous cuts in staffing in places such as Philadelphia, Atlanta and possibly in New York. Smaller communities are also being hit hard.

While the grant required hard work the ability to use it required forward thinking skills. Kudos to Chief Carr.

February 04, 2009

Charleston Fire Department Receives Over Two Million In Grant For Staffing

Fire Chief Tom Carr was notified the department received a grant to put 24 additional firefighters on the floor. Unlike some departments who had to turn down the grant money Charleston kept matching funds to be able to utilize the grant. The $2.53 million will allow Charleston to put firefighters on the floor.

Congratulations to Chief Carr and the Charleston Fire Department.

We will discuss it next on the podcast.

January 25, 2009

Charleston Mayor's State Of the City Address Should Mention Firefighters

Charleston Mayor Joe Riley will give his state of the city address Tuesday night from city council chambers. Most feel he will discuss economic issues. The Post & Courier said they expect the mayor to discuss how the city has avoided many of the economic problems facing America.

One area of interest to firefighters is what the mayor says about the fire department. This is the first state of the city speech given after the hiring of Tom Carr as fire chief. It's expected the mayor will make mention of the fire department.

If not, the mayor should consider it. Charleston is still in the national spotlight and firefighters have more than done their part to bring the department back. It should be a source of pride but one never knows how politics will play out, especially when dealing with the aftermath of a tragedy.

January 22, 2009

Memorial For Charleston 9 Could Begin In June

The on site memorial for the nine firefighters who perished on June 18, 2007 could begin as early as June of this year. According to a report in the News & Courier the memorial would have:

 two buildings that could house training classrooms, offices, a lecture hall, an emergency dispatch center and a room to display mementos and artifacts associated with the blaze.

The proposed centerpiece of the plan is a memorial garden with an eternal flame, trickling water and monuments to the nine firefighters.

The plans are along the lines of what many firefighters have talked about over the past six months.

January 20, 2009

Seminar In Charleston To Feature Montgomery County Battalion Chief John Tippett

A seminar open to firefighters for free will take place January 27, 28 or 29 at the Galliard Auditorium in Charleston.

Image003

January 19, 2009

NIOSH Report On Sofa Super Store Fire Could Be Out Soon

The NIOSH final report on the deaths of nine Charleston firefighters could come out within the next week or two. The report would follow the Routley Report leaving only the NIST model report left to come out within the next year.

NIOSH conducts Line of Duty Deaths  as part of their Firefighter Fatality Investigation and Prevention Program. It's widely though the NIOSH report will cover the same issues released by the Routley Report with little new information available.

One area some firefighters are concentrating on is the SCBA evaluation. Others see the NIOSH report as simply confirming the issues put together by Chief Gordon Routley and his panel of experts.

Still another group of people feel the legal issueswill be enhanced by the report from NIOSH, a branch of the CDC. This group believes this year will be a very active year on the legal front.

NIOSH released a draft report last year.

January 15, 2009

Charleston Fire Department Warns Of Fire Dangers

Time to Check Home Heating Systems and Smoke Alarms

As cold temperatures embrace the Charleston area, The Charleston Fire Department offer some safety tips. The winter months are typically the busiest time of the year for firefighters. Cooking, home heating systems, heating equipment and associated electrical systems, as well as holiday decorations too close to a heat source continuously are a significant factor in structural fires in Charleston. Many of these fires can be prevented. The following fire safety tips and information can help you maintain a fire safe home and business this winter.

* Be sure your heater is in good working condition. Inspect exhaust parts for carbon build-up. Inspect electrical systems for overloads.

* Never use fuel burning appliances without proper room venting. Burning fuel such as kerosene, coal or propane, for (example) produces deadly fumes.

* Keep young children safely away from space heaters -- especially when they are wearing night clothes or other loose clothing that can be easily ignited. Give space heaters space!

REMINDERS:
• Kitchen Fires. Most kitchen fires occur because food is left unattended on the stove or in the oven. If you must leave the kitchen while cooking, take a spoon or potholder with you to remind you to return to the kitchen. Never cook with loose, dangling sleeves that can ignite easily. Heat cooking oils gradually and use extra caution when deep-frying. If a fire breaks out in a pan, put a lid on the pan. Never throw water on a grease fire. Never use a range or stove to heat your home.

• Space Heaters. Buy only Underwriter's Laboratory (UL) approved heaters. Use only the manufacturer's recommended fuel for each heater. Do not use electric space heaters in the bathroom or around other wet areas. Do not dry or store objects on top of your heater. Keep combustibles away from heat sources. Give space heaters space!

• Smoking. We prefer that you don’t smoke at all, but if you must - Don't leave smoking materials unattended. Use "safety ashtrays" with wide lips. Empty all ashtrays into the toilet or a metal container every night before going to bed. Never smoke in bed. Don’t smoke when drowsy.
• Candles. Keep burning candles out of children’s and pet’s reach; keep matches and lighters out of sight and locked away. Make sure they are in stable holders. Do not leave candles unattended – especially around children or pets. Do not place candles near draperies or anything that might easily catch fire. Make sure you put out candles when you go to bed or leave the home.

• Fireplace Ashes. Remember never discard hot ashes inside or near the home. Place them in a metal container outside and well away from the house. Have your furnace and chimney professionally inspected and cleaned. Chimney tar build-up can ignite your chimney, roof and the whole house.

It is important that all residents know to have a working smoke alarm on each level of a home, have an escape plan (know how to get out quickly) and call the fire department from a safe area, preferably a neighbor’s house. Do not delay. 

FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Mark Ruppel
Public Information Officer
(843) 693 – 4386 (CELL)
(843) 720 – 1981 (OFFICE)
mruppel@ci.charleston.sc.us

Banner

Search FF Hourly

  • Google

    WWW
    http://www.firefighterhourly.com/

FirefighterHourly.com

FirefighterHourly.com Newsletter

  • Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for our Email Newsletter

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Must Visits

    Blog Widget by LinkWithin

    Stay Safe!

    Firefighter Hourly

    • Remembering:

      Charleston 9
      FDNY 343
      Worcester 6

      Firefighter Hourly provides commentary on issues relevant to the fire service.

      Dedicated to:
      Andrew Fredericks, FDNY
      William Hutchinson, CFD

      Copyright 2009. All Rights Reserved.

    Get Our Feed

    Daily Quote

    • "So they [the Government] go on in strange paradox, decided only to be undecided, resolved to be irresolute, adamant for drift, solid for fluidity, all-powerful to be impotent. "

      WS Churchill


      Our Motto

      "Let no man's ghost return to say his training let him down." --Old Fire Service Saying

    Advertising

    IAFF Award 2008

    Firefighter Hourly Shirts

    E-Med Classes